As long time readers of my barely-intelligible howlings will know, I generally have no love, patience or pity for “revenue generating sports” at the college level. The most charitable good-faith interpretation I can muster is that a relatively innocent but stupidly naive concept of the virtues of “amateurism” was corrupted at least 75 years ago and has only gotten more rancid as the money has skyrocketed for everyone except the ones actually playing the games. As we watched young men (and now women!) sacrifice their bodies and psyches before a live TV audience for someone else’s benefit, there was a slow dawning comprehension: maybe this is Bullshit. Perhaps more importantly, there was a slow dawning comprehension in the federal judiciary that there was no principled reason to give a pass to the NCAA-Industrial Complex solely on grounds of That’s How It’s Always Been.
In a move that can only be described as a modern-day Munich Agreement, the NCAA tried to stave off treating “the people who make the institutions money” as “workers” by allowing third parties to pay athletes for their Name, Image and Likeness rights, under the pretense that athletes were therefore not being paid to incentivize them to perform services for a specific school. And like the Munich Agreement, only the most willfully blind pollyannas believed this had bought Peace in Our Time.
NIL, combined with the Transfer Portal, has forced open acknowledgement of what used to be discussed only in sanctions and indictments: coaches bitching about how some other coach bought a great team, loud complaints about players lacking “loyalty” from one of the most grifting mercenary asshole coaches (who was a diva asshole mercenary player), and Matt Rhule straight up telling the press that a good transfer quarterback “costs” $1-2 million to land.
Everyone knew at the time NIL was a transparent sham that wouldn’t fool a child who has realized their uncle does not, in fact, “got [their] nose.” The question was basically how long before it all collapsed.
Turns out that Munich Agreement analogy may hold there as well. With the implosion of the PAC 12 into the PAC 2, teams hopping conferences openly and solely for money, and university presidents taking the place of athletic directors in the crosshairs of angry fanbases, the NCAA brass met:
And lo! New NCAA Head Sockpuppet Charlie Baker has come out with proposed new rules to allow colleges to…pay NIL directly to athletes. Presumably, this is because calling it “payment for services” would make athletes into employees, with all the pesky worker protections that entails.
It would also allow colleges who put up a certain amount of money to join a new sub-subdivision (Division I, FBS, Champagne Room Tier) which can set its own rules regarding transfers, roster size, scholarships, etc., presumably so that the Power 5 (4?) Conference programs can set rules to let them spend in recruiting and suppress transfers within the VIP Section.
This sounds very much like the culmination of a thousand Southern sports radio callers’ secret theories- that the SEC and Big 10 are conspiring to swallow up the big teams from every other conference to form a Super League knockoff.
And to that I say: no shit. There are a limited number of media outlets with whom conferences can negotiate media rights. The fewer conferences the average fan wants to watch, the more those conferences can demand at the bargaining table. And this lets the big programs operate without having to court the votes of the Campbell University Fighting Camels.
I have called for college “revenue sports” to be broken off into what they really are: minor league teams. And this is a welcome first step for that- because they can just hand recruits giant bags of cash, universities like Cal won’t have to go into hock to compete on “facilities” or whatever. Brave new world out there.
NFL NEWS
Not much. Lot of ded quarterbacks (TrevoUr Lawrence, Kenny Pickett, Tim Boyle). Lot of quarterbacks wish were ded (Tommy DeVito, Baker Mayfield, Jameis Winston)
Underappreciated Movie of the Week:
Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure
Big win for the Fightin’ Horatios, (obviously basketball; the phrase ‘big win’ should have made it clear I wasn’t talking about football), against UNC. Played a frustrating and inconsistent game but still beat the #9 team by 11 on a neutral, (not really. MSG is a second home for UConn), court.
I’ll be up for a while buzzing about that one. And what is my reward? Jerry Jones talking about how he thinks Dallas will beat Philly Sunday. Goddamn bridge troll has learned nothing over the years. Take Philly and the over.
And the Lakers’ getting to THE TOURNAMENT semis in Vegas was the icing.
For me.
IU, do good?
And I don’t even have the lucky picture out yet
Ice Rams beat the Ice Buckeyes in OT to start the season 10-0-0 in road games, tying an NHL record.
LA IS HOCKEYTOWN
WHICH NY TEAM ARE WE BEATING FOR THE CUP THIS YEAR???
I guess it’s the Isles’ turn.
Hee hee…
“I will make you a Fisher of Islas…”
Goddamn Borat.
*checks standings* Igor Shesterkin, come on down in your next iteration of Henrik Lundqvist impersonation!
/Even if they lost to the fightin’ Maestros tonight
You’re the next contestant on “Waste Your Prime!”
Day #5
Violence is the best. But gin is also pretty good.
I like gin. My wife said it was a paint thinner Advent calendar.
She’s thinking of the cheap vodka calendar.
This is great:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/columnist/2023/12/04/florida-state-college-football-playoff-selection-rigged/71802654007/
Too bad that argument only works on idiots. 😁
*Argument only works on idiots
An edit, an edit, my kingdom for a fucking working edit function.
Done and done.
Speak kindly of me when The Emperor returns.
I like the theory that Disney got ESPN to sway the decision to punish DeSantis
I do appreciate this Rev Rant. In fact, I made the same arguments myself for time. I’m over it. I’m leaning in on the masses being stupid.
In fact, I’m thinking of getting $65 together and buying some Kenyans to win Arizona a XC Nat’l Championship.
What will you do with the other fifty dollars?
It’s about time they subdivided FBS. It should realistically be cut in half.
And I still like the relegation/promotion model that had been floated around for the Mountain West/PAC 2.
https://youtu.be/j9yBPcn8IqU?si=ibtT-_yT-6gY1Xir
Gumby and I are going to see Stevie Nicks tonight. And I bought the tickets, so no, it won’t be the Cult! Later, taters
Enjoy Stevie Wonder!
Gonna be REAL awkward when turns out they’re Stevie Ray Vaughn tickets.
Definitely bought tickets to see “Nick Stahl Reads Selections From The Terminator 3 Script” followed by Q&A.
Hey, it means they saw Stevie… but Stevie didn’t see them!
/It’s a Padre Weaselo at NAMM joke!
Enjoy supper!
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3s9vt2
Are you sure it’s not tickets to Seedy Nick?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gctmy_Eu1wo
I’ve already started thinking about New Year’s and I’m gonna resolve to hunt down and kill the bastard who invented non-popping bubble wrap
I refuse to believe such an abomination exists. You just need a mallet or something
Bill and Ted was an excellent movie (no pun intended). While it wasn’t a cinematic masterpiece, at no point did it feel was droning on or waiting for the plot to occur. It also had smart jokes here and there to show it wasn’t just a movie about two idiots traveling in time, While I have issues with it’s time travel mechanics, it doesn’t draw away from the movie.
As for the other two, Bogus Journey and Face The Music wasn’t as good but it did have its moment or two.
SAN DIMAS HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL RULES!!
In a quirky bit of coincidence, I drove through San Dimas today!
I dated a girl who had a house out in San Dimas, and spent more than a few nights out there. It was most excellent.
Congrats on the sex.
One thing that is easy to overlook about the movie is that Missy (I mean “Mom”) actually tries pretty hard to be a good stepmom.
I 100% agree with this NCAA rant. The whole amateurism thing is classist bullshit, but the NCAA isn’t even amateurism when it’s a mandatory step before going pro like in football.
There must be some collusion with the NFL going on, because the NFL could very easily support a minor league of college age kids that would play the same feeder role as the NCAA as well as making money in it’s own right
They tried it a while back, with the We-Laugh (World League of American Football). We had a team in Columbus, the Ohio Glory. I never went to a game, but did see Major Harris (played for the Glory) and some of his teammates bowling one night.
I think the NFL just doesn’t want to spend that much money.
I think the NFL just doesn’t want to spend the money
This comment is bang-on. I think the NFL could grow the brand far more than they have but Goodell and Company are bottom-line watchers, misers that want to hug their pot of money. Why would they ever try to grow the business in any way if it doesn’t immediately grow their bottom line?
It’s a free farm system. Why the fuck would they put a penny into it?
I was referencing the oddball pro leagues that pop up and fail every time within 24 months.
I think it’s less about money and more about how it would be impossible to replicate the college experience – which, if you are an athlete at a top-tier program, absolutely *rules*.
The Glory would have been good if not for all the holes on the roster.
They could, but if they pay them the same as MiLB players get, that would open up a whole other can of worms.
Excellent post! Always felt the players should get a cut of the money.