One of the biggest things I miss from our old site was the mock drafts that used to run every Friday. Those were fantastic time wasters, and a good one was a virtual guarantee that you were going to be far from productive at work, as your day instead degenerated into arguments with strangers over who would be the best Saturday cartoon character to have sex with, (and now we all know how that would go), or some other equally inane topic, all of which were still more important than that TPS report deadline your boss was yelling about. Good times.
Well, it’s been long enough. After a discussion in the back channels yours truly is bringing it back, with some slight rule changes. The old site had 4-5 main contributors, one of whom may not have been real. So they’d do 2-3 rounds themselves, then kick it to the kommentariat to draft whatever was left over. You can do that when you’ve only taken 10-15 of whatever topic was up for drafting. We, however, are a much more connected group when it comes to the writin’ and draftin’ of things, so if we did that we’d easily take out 30-50 before we threw the bedraggled leftovers to our beloved readership. That’s no fun. So these drafts will just leap right into it.
Also, for content and alliteration reasons, we’ve moved the draft to Monday mornings, so get ready to kill your productivity right from the start.
First come, first served, subject to my randomly assigning the first pick to someone else, generally because they came up with the idea. Or because they bribed me. For now, please wait 10 picks or 30 minutes before making another one.
This week’s subject comes from Twitter thread I’m involved in with some people from KSK and DFO, although I don’t think any of them are all that active around here these days. Maybe we should air out the Clubhouse? Eh, seems like work.
Anyhoo, one of them, Duchess to be exact, was talking about persons being perfectly case for roles. A couple of names and films were tossed back and forth and a lightbulb went off above my head. After replacing that bulb, and brushing the glass out of what’s left of my hair, I went back into the conversation and it would eventually occurred to me that this would be a good draft topic. I did tell them that I’d be using it, so perhaps one of more old friends will stumble by.
This week’s topic is an actor or actress you feel was perfectly cast in a movie or on a TV show. I’d say plays, too, but that seems like a waste on a group like us whose main ambition is to spend as much time inside as possible and as little of that time wearing pants as is possible. So movies and TV shows it is.
With the first pick of the draft I will take the actor and role that Duchess started the conversation with, James Gandolfini as Tony Soprano.
Yeah, he’s the featured image, too. The casting was that good.
The rest of you are now on the clock,
Will Ferrell as Ron Burgundy
Gene Wilder as Jim in Blazing Saddles
https://youtu.be/ZZvT2r828QY
John Ratzenberger as Cliff Clavin
I always thought casting David Bowie as Andy Warhol in Basquiat was inspired.
Bill Murray as Dr. Peter Venkman:
Martin Sheen as President Bartlet. He went from rarely seen background character to main cast in one scene!
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CTG5p4wEAAM
Great pick
Speaking of The West Wing, Josh Malina is officially now a friend of the site:
If anyone finds themselves doing a rewatch of The West Wing, I recommend to you the The West Wing Weekly podcast, co-hosted by Malina.
Whenever I watch or re-watch an older show, it’s often weird not having anyone to discuss it with, so a podcast that goes episode-by-episode like that is nice, and they got a lot of great guest interviews with the rest of the cast, writers, directors, crew, as well as various political figures past and present discussing the policy issues.
Not a pick, just an observation. Doctor Who fandom goes through this cycle:
Stage 1: “Oh no, Actor 1 has announced his departure as the Nth Doctor! I can’t image how they’ll replace him, it was such an iconic portrayal!”
Stage 2: “They’ve cast Actor 2 to be the N+1th Doctor? I can’t see him/her as the Doctor!”
Stage 3: “Actor 2’s first couple of episodes were ok, but I still miss Actor 1.”
Stage 4: “The N+1th Doctor is my favorite!”
Stage 5: “Oh no, Actor 2 has announced his/her departure as the N+1th Doctor! I can’t imagine how they’ll replace him/her, it was such an iconic portrayal!”
I always thought that Tilda Swinton made a great Archangel Gabriel in Constantine. That was some creative casting.
Lovey!!!
Lovie!! (Showing his emotional range)
They really missed out not casting him as one of the Terminators, or perhaps as a brick wall…
Marlon Brando as Don Corleone. I don’t think there’s any further explanation needed.
https://youtu.be/SeldwfOwuL8
Fair warning, I’m going on a ‘Cheers’ run here, so if you were thinking of taking any other actors from what might have been the best cast show ever, get ’em in now.
Bebe Neuwirth as Dr. Lilith Sternin Crane
Seleccion el fin – Jessica Walter as Lucille Bluth:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EW_tlvW4aI
Yes!
JK Simmons as J Jonah Jameson
He’s had better roles, but I agree he perfectly embodied JJJ.
James Garner as Jim Rockford. If they ever reboot this show again, I will personally burn said network to the ground.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1zYNrsx9Pw
Angelica Houston as Mortcia Adams.
Is Raul Julia on the board? If so, we all deserve a -1. Actually a -2.
Oooo. Good point. That’s horrible hustle, people. We suck.
Or you could just draft him.
And ruin all the angst? I think not, my good man.
“Brett Favre as Brett Favre in ‘There’s Something About Mary.’ It’s the role he was born to play, and I think I think he should have gotten an Oscar.” — Peter King
He would have won the Oscar if the award ceremony was held in Wichita!
Maybe!
Kyle MacLachlan as Muad’dib
“What do you call the mouse shadow on the second moon?”
/Timothee’ Shamalama sobs quietly.
What a ding dong
He’ll get over it once he hits puberty.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9lz_yzrGZw
Is anyone going to take Hayden Christensen in hahahahaha I couldn’t even finish that
Are you talking about a movie where he plays an emotionless tree? Because I think he’d be perfect for that one!
Vin Diesel tries (and fails) to emote his displeasure at this.
I tend to fault Lucas with the poor script and worse direction on that one.
+1 “Faster, More Intense”
He was rather well cast in “Shattered Glass”, I would say. He plays a petulant little shithead who is in over his head rather well…
Gene Wilder in Willy Wonka. Johnny Depp showed just how perfect Wilder was in the role
Getting Sir Alec Guinness to play Obi Wan was quite a coup…
Ewan McGregor will be the late round pick of this draft that becomes an all star by pure effort on a poor team.
Jason Sudeikis as Ted Lasso. Writing is amazing, but that character does not work without him.
A couple of ‘Cheers’ picks off the board, and while I think Danson was the best example for this draft, (and there’s at least three more who should be drafted), for my money Nicholas Colasanto as Coach is right there with him.
Rachel Griffiths as Brenda Chenowith (“Six Feet Under”) – if you haven’t seen that series, SHAME ON YOU, and rectify it immediately.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HjOJ31m3t_Y
That’s an excellent value pick.
Stephen Colbert as Stephen Colbert. Seriously. He was able to play someone who was politically the complete opposite of himself, but not come off as wrong, just a nice, patriotic idiot who means well.
Jim Rash in “Community”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FnBPp7-zEk
Agreed. That character absolutely stole that show.
Alan Rickman as Severus Snape.
Given that Jackie, Burt, Sally, and Jerry were all known to be perfectly cast, I present to you the one person that was completely overlooked in Smokey and The Bandit: Paul Williams as Little Enos Burdette
“Michael J. Fox as Marty McFly,” — Robert Zemeckis, glancing furtively at Eric Stolz
Barney Fife as Mr. Furley
The animated “The Hobbit” movie from the 70ies had some issues, but casting John Houston as the voice actor for Gandalf the Grey was genius.
Walton Goggins as Boyd Crowder from Justified.
Pick el dos – can’t believe Bryan Cranston is still on the board:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dy_DASt7hDs
Dunno who else could have done it.
Ricky Gervais played the same role, although as I’ve never seen the British version I have no opinion as to whether or not he would have done as well in the US.
In Steve Carell’s last season, there was a scene with them together. It was weird.
I found it to be pretty awesome, as an homage to the original.
If you’ve seen the first season of the US version, you’ve more or less seen the British version. Although the British version is somehow even more awkward.
Bruce Willis as John McClain.
Katie Holmes’s breasts in The Gift. They did a fantastic job.
If we’re going that route, Kate Winslet’s in Titanic. It really connected both halves of the movie together.
I wouldn’t know; I’ve never watched past the scene. Or before it.
Good call. It’s not a complete waste of time, the acting is good and the special effects somewhat hold up, but it’s not the masterpiece everyone says it is.
Pick by proxy, from all Latin Americans:
Donald J. Trump, U.S.A. President. Hit all the familiar notes.
Disallowed.
He’s not the President anymore.
(I actually don’t care, I just really love pointing out that Donald Trump isn’t the President anymore.)
Yet at least.
He was, truly, the God of Tits & Wine
These are the four kids from The Wire, in case anybody is CTRL-F’ing.
Pick one, you greedy bastard.
People from Baltimore only count as 1/4 of a person.
Touche’
How about these go in as picks 1-4 and I have to wait that many cycles before I submit my next pick (Oscar-winner Kobe Bryant for his role in Crash).
I’m going to disallow the Kobe pick because, let’s face it, Britt Reid would have been much better in Crash.
Robert Downey Jr as billionaire, playboy philanthropist Tony Stark.
(kicking myself for starting with obscure picks)
That would have been my pick.
Really, nearly the entire MCU. They have by and large done a masterful job of casting.
Ian McDiarmid as Palpatine in the Star Wars movies. After being built up for two movies, he shows up in VI to live up the billing. And when he returns for the prequels, you can see the subdued part of the character. The controlling. The manipulative. McDiarmid understood his character better than Lucas.
I’m willing to forgive/forget IX as by that point they were just trying to land the plane without crashing it.
“McDiarmid understood his character better than Lucas.”
Literally everyone involved in those movies understood their characters better than Lucas. See, e.g. Harrison Ford going with “I know” instead of “I love you too”, the way Lucas had it.
As usual, Patton Oswalt said it best:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LDCjIjsZp_Y
I’ll go with Mr. Blake Lively again with Van Wilder. No one else could have played that role.
I knew I had to take DP first. Van Wilder was the one I was debating about.choosing. Nice pick!
Robert Shaw as Captain Quint in “Jaws.”
Danny Trejo as Danny Trejo
And then following it up as the character “Trejo” in the movie Heat.
Nice choice in Draft.
I’m going to show my nerd off and go with Nana Visitor as Kira Nerys from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. She was the producers 2nd choice when they couldn’t get Michelle Forbes to commit to a fill series as Ro Laren, but it worked out greater in the long run.
Visitor was able to play Kira as stubborn and hard willed yet have a caring softer side. Also, it did hurt that Visitor has the acting chops to pull it off. I would recommend “Duet” as it shows off what I just wrote.
Ted Danson as Sam Malone (that’s “Cheers” for you young folk/philistines).
Fucker. He was my second pick.
He was on my draft board too
Mr Blake Lively as my first pick playing Deadpool
Nice pick. That would have been my #1.
He was mentioned very early in the conversation Duchess started.
Sir Ian McKellen as Gandalf
Mel Blanc as the voice actor for every single animated character basically until the 1980s
Sir Patrick Stewart as Professor Charles Xavier
/James McAvoy sobs softly
I was under the impression that McAvoy was a time displaced younger version of Stewart. Am I mistaken?
McAvoy plays him as the pre-spinal injury Xavier. He’s good, but Patrick Stewart is the better fit for the more known role.
Yeah, and of course McAvoy would have been way too young at the time Stewart was cast in the role. I’m just making a joke that the character has been played well by someone else.
He’s like Steve Young of the Professor Xs: They did a great job and bring different things to the table, but they’re forever cursed with the title “Second Best”.
Kelsey Grammer as Frasier in Frasier. No one else could have been him (after Cheers).