DRAFT NIGHT OPEN THREAD! (plus Reverend Mayhem’s 2024 Final Mock Draft)

So here we are. Clock is ticking. Mistakes will be made, both happy accidents and career-ending missteps. Christmas Morning for our deviant kind.

Ho ho ho, bitches.

As predicted, whole lotta bullshit spewing from all quarters. Also as predicted, I am not immune to the Draft Brain Slugs that infect the media and GMs alike:

“DRAFT A TIGHT END IN THE TOP 10. THIS TIME IT WILL BE DIFFERENT.”

So while I’m mostly sticking by my guns here, there are some changes. I will note where things diverge from Mock Draft 1: The Motion Picture

1. Chicago Bears (from Carolina): Caleb Williams (Quarterback, USC)

Would it be both hilarious and on-brand for the Bears to draft JJ McCarthy? Yes, and only the fact that it is literally impossible for them to trade up further to do so keeps it from being Perfect. Alas, even a blind squirrel may find the occasional nut. The question then becomes whether they know which end to stick it in.

2. Washington Commanders: Drake Maye (Quarterback, U*NC)

3. New England Patriots: Jayden Daniels (Quarterback, LSU)

I’m sticking with this, in the face of a YUUUGE amount of smoke about 1. Washington coordinator Kliff Kingsbury preferring more mobile quarterbacks like Daniels, and 2. New England being “open for business” in the words of their de facto Draft Czar Eliot Wolf, and speculation that they may trade down for McCarthy (or take him outright at 3).

First: Dan Quinn strikes me as a “the best ability is availability” meathead, and I think Daniels’ reckless running style scares him and GM Adam Peters.

Second: Wolf knows his business. From ages 9 to 35, he was raised in an environment where quarterback talent and stability were the first and last words in team success. Since then, his teams have lived and (more often) died on inconsistent quarterback play. Let no one fool you: McCarthy is more of a project than the media suggests, and there’s no Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers for him to sit behind for two years while he seasons. Bob Kraft may have this great reputation as a patient owner, but it’s not a situation he’s had to deal with much since he bought the team 30 years ago  When he did, he fired Pete Carroll the first season Carroll didn’t make the playoffs. He’s also 82, and a developmental quarterback is not a great fit with his actuarial table. The Pats take the talent and roll with it, unless they already have a deal to trade down (Raiders?) and then back up to 5 for McCarthy.

4. Arizona Cardinals- Marvin Harrison, Jr. (WR, An Ohio State University)

5. Minnesota Vikings (via Los Angeles Chargers)- JJ McCarthy (QB, Michigan)

It’s still too high for him, but this is the price of doing business in a year of many needy teams. Darnold will start, McCarthy will be rushed in around their bye week, struggles will ensue.

6. New York Giants- Malik Nabers (WR- LSU)

Sorry, Giants fans. They have too many holes to piss away assets trading up, and I will eat a Big Turk (the candy bar- DFO does not condone cannibalism unless stranded at sea, and then only after 18 hours) if one of the Big 3.5 quarterbacks makes it this far. You’ll just have to content yourself with an amazingly talented receiver

7. Tennessee Titans- Joe Alt (Tackle- Notre Dame)

8. Atlanta Falcons- Dallas Turner (Defensive End, Alabama)

9. Bearistocrats (again)- Jared Verse (Defensive End, Florida State)

An alternate line of thought has emerged that the Bears may go O-Line here. While more plausible than the GET CALEB ANOTHER WEAPON calls to The Score, I don’t see it unless they trade back another seven (or more) places.

10. J-E-S-T JEST JEST JEST- Brock Bowers (Tight End- Georgia)

11. Las Vegas Raiders (Trade from Chargers from Vikings) Michael Penix Jr. (QB, Washington).

HODL! Shit in that soup, Mark Davis!

12. Denver Broncos- Terrion Arnold (CB- Alabama) FORMERLY Quinyon Mitchell, (CB- Toledo)

Please: check on your Bronco fan friends. They are probably Not Ok. The team traded for Zach Wilson as “insurance” for Jarrett Stidham. Which is like getting insurance for a 1989 Geo Metro.

Right now, a significant number of Denver fans are looking at this and going “dear god, Sean Payton is so delusional about his ability to mold quarterbacks he’s going to ride this flaming wagon of dogshit all the way into Hell, and we are all strapped in as unwilling passengers.”

And maybe he is. Remember, Denver has no second round pick- because they traded it for Payton himself.  Drafting Bo Nix at 12 would be Football Malpractice. Drafting him in the mid-third round is probably not an option. So if they can’t trade down to 29-50, maybe Payton decides he can Make Magic all on his own.

I considered Odunze here, but if Payton is delusional enough to think he can make something out of Stidham, he’s delusional enough to trust his current receivers. The Broncos signed Levi Wallace, but signing Levi Wallace is not a solution. Again, they are desperate to trade down, and I would be shocked if they pick here. But if they do, I think they go cornerback

13. Los Angeles Chargers- Rome Odunze (WR- Washington)

14. New Orleans Saints- Olumuyiwa Fashanu (Tackle, Penn State).

15. Indianapolis Clots-Troy Fautanu (Offensive Line- Washington) PREVIOUSLY Brian Thomas, Jr. (WR- LSU)

Fresh news: Jim Irsay will not be present in the draft room while recovers from “back surgery for an old powerlifting injury.” That’s right, nothing to do with any “Massive Overdose of Powdered Orphan Pineal Gland” or anything…

Irsay will ostensibly be participating by phone. However, look for Chris Ballard to fake “technical difficulties” on the phone line and draft for both value and need here.

16. Seattle Seahawks- Jackson Powers-Johnson (Center, Oregon) FORMERLY Troy Fautanu (Offensive Line- Washington)

JPJ isn’t as good, but this is what comes of a rational Colts team in front of you.

17. jacksonville jaguars: Quinyon Mitchell (Cornerback, Toledo) PREVIOUSLY Terrion Arnold (Cornerback, Alabama)

The Smart Money is now on the jags to trade down with almost any willing partner. But for now, they go for the highest remaining guy at cornerback (which is now Mitchell).

18. Cincinnnananti Bengals: JC Latham (Right Tackle, Alabama)

19. Los Angeles Rams: Byron Murphy II (Defensive Tackle, Texas)

I am deeply tempted to change this to Bo Nix. Sean McVay has never had a first-round draft pick. GM Les Snead has had one since the Rams fucked off for Los Angeles 8 years ago, and it was Jared Goff. Matt Stafford is 36, and not a lightly-used 36: leaving aside his anatomy-textbook list of injuries, he’s been sacked 489 times for 3,243 yards. That’s almost as many yards as Ryan Leaf put up passing in his career. Nix could comfortably sit for a year or two, and Sean McVay would have a reason to skip his annual retirement talk as he molds a young passer.

If their defense didn’t suddenly have an Aaron Donald-shaped hole in the middle, I would actually consider this- but they do. If they trade back to the end of Round 1 or beginning of Round 2, a Nix pick becomes much more likely.

20. Pittsburgh Steelers: Brian Thomas Jr. (WR, LSU) FORMERLY Jackson Powers-Johnson (Center, Oregon)

Pittsburgh gets lucky here. They get a choice between the last top-tier receiver or auctioning him off to the Packers, Chiefs, Bills, etc. for a very good return. If it were solely Mike Tomlin’s call, I don’t they would ever draft a wideout in the first round. But with two quarterbacks on tryout periods, it may make sense here.

21. Miami Whalesnacks: Laiatu Latu (DE, UCLA)

22. Philadelphia Eagles: Cooper DeJean (Cornerback, Iowa)

I am increasingly certain of this pick. It just…has to happen.

23. Los Angeles Chargers (From MIN from CLE from HOU): Taliese Fuaga (Tackle, Oregon State)

I keep seeing that Fuaga won’t last this long. Frankly, if we’ve gotten this far and my picks are within two lightyears of reality and the issue is which tackle I got wrong, I’m going to play the lottery.

24. Dallas Cowpersons: Amarius Mims (Tackle, Georgia)

25. Green Bay Packers: Ladd McConkey (WR, Georgia)

Actually, I have greater faith in McConkey going at this spot than predicting which team will be here to take him. I think the Ravens may reach here and snag him.

26. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Chop Robinson (DE/OLB, Penn State)

Pork. Chop.

27. Arizona Cardinals: Kool-Aid McKinstry (Cornerback, Alabama)

28. Most Glorious Buffalo Bills: Adonai Mitchell

God help me, I’m talking myself into Mitchell. Just please don’t piss away more draft capital to jump up.

29. Detroit Lions: Nate Wiggins (Cornerback, Clemson) 

30. Baltimore Ravens: Johnny Newton (DT, Illinois) FORMERLY Tyler Guyton (Tackle, Oklahoma)

I psyched myself out on this. They should go offense. Specifically, O-line (unless they trade up for a better receiver than is available here). But it’s the Ravens. They are constitutionally unable to pass up a great prospect up the middle of the defense. They re-signed nose tackle Michael Pierce to a very cheap $7.5 million, 2 year deal this offseason. Even Pierce was surprised by this. They signed DT Justin Madubuike to a rich contract, this gives them the cheap talent to complement him.

31. San Francisco 49ers: Graham Barton (OT/Guard, Duke) PREVIOUSLY Christian Haynes (Guard, UConn)

Shuffling because the Niners need a right tackle now and a guard in the next year or so. Barton played tackle, but (to listen to the Draft Industrial Complex) he has wee tiny baby arms fit only for a guard. So maybe he plays a year at tackle and if he can’t hack it, slides inside.

32. Albuquerque Chiefs: Tyler Guyton (Tackle, Oklahoma) PREVIOUSLY Sydney Sweeney (DD, Idaho)

All prior joking aside, the Chiefs find themselves in a precarious position for a back-to-back Super Bowl Champion. Their need for receiver help is well-documented, but the top of the crop is gone by this point, leaving a bubbling stew of second and third round pass-catchers who will live or die on scheme fit and luck.

Less well-documented is the fact that their offensive line is thin, with a giant hole at left tackle. It’ll drive the Chiefs fans crazy, but solidifying the line with cheap young talent is a force-multiplier for every other part of the offense: it makes Mahomes more effective, reduces the risk of him being pulped into hummus, and makes the running game a more legitimate threat, all while freeing up salary cap room. All Kansas City really needs at receiver is a couple of guys whose hands are not stone and whose fingers are not butter. Much easier to find those later in this draft than a Day 1 starter at offensive tackle.

So there we go.

5 5 votes
Article Rating
The Right Reverend Electric Mayhem
Feared conqueror; scholar; poet; revered holy man; professional raconteur; soldier of fortune; aloof yet thorough lover; bandit; blazing gypsy speedboat. I have been called some of these things.
Subscribe
Notify of
454 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Doktor Zymm

SUPPLEMENT

3f12d143a833fa969b7589b1fb78f119.png
King Hippo

JESUS FUCKING CHRIST, what is wrong with these Wal-Mart fuckstains.

(teevee box off)

Gatoraids

Denver spans with their hat tributes to Manning

SonOfSpam

Nix vs Wilson is a zesty QB battle.

(like something zesty, you don’t want it in your eyes)

makeitsnowondem

Hold up, we didn’t re-sign– oh.

SonOfSpam

Cougar boy is gonna wreck Littleton-area housewives

scotchnaut

“The greatest trick that the devil Harbaugh ever pulled was convincing the world that JJ McCarthy was a viable starting QB in the NFL.”

-Charles Baudelaire, NFL scout

Gumbygirl

The Jest aren’t even slightly Jesting here. Good pick, and they got two extra picks. I feel like this might be a sign of an imminent apocalypse. Stop drop and roll!

WCS

Is that… a reasonably good pick for the Jets?

Spur

Donks select to outlaw the forward pass

King Hippo

hey now, we’d rather not highlight our run game neither

Cecil Rhodes

My word! The Jets just drafted my primary manservant! What a shame — he makes an outstanding zebra sandwich (despite being uncivilized!).

SonOfSpam

Which makes me and his family happy.

Doktor Zymm

With all this extra protection it’s gonna be a non-contact injury that takes Qaaron out this year

Spur

MORE time for podcasting!

King Hippo

Bowers or CB, snow?

Spur

new ears for Rodgers to annoy

SonOfSpam

Jets did a smart?

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Why move up one pick for McCarthy though? Clearly the Jets weren’t gonna take him so….why not stand pat? Who else was going to trade up to take JJ?

BrettFavresColonoscopy

I don’t believe you on either. Call the Jets bluff.

King Hippo

pretended Donks or Raiders would, seems like

Spur

Jets select a tour of Dulce Base and a tin of energy boast super max all natural crystal crunch mix

Spur

am ok with this for the Viks. the real question is how much did Coach hold him back from throwing?

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Well now he should be able to afford some socks.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Sam Darnold doesn’t understand this pick.

Not because of the competition, he’s just dumb.

makeitsnowondem

Kiper calling Sam Darnold a ‘bridge quarterback’ has me picturing Mothman.

WCS

That’s Banner material.

Spur

Its JJ time

scotchnaut

“Dynomite!”

/look at me, being so old!

Gumbygirl

.

images (69) (17).jpeg
SonOfSpam

JJ McCarthy is a winner, like Danny Kanell.

litre_cola

JJ is like Tebow, but strength more arm, less filipino circumcisions.

SonOfSpam

QBs should be surgical.

Redshirt

If Minnesota traded up for a punter…

Spur

Vikings select to let the clock run out picking a player for memories

WCS

Sorry yeah right

Yeah wrong?

Redshirt

…and Vikings as expected reach for McCarthy.

SonOfSpam

Cormac?

makeitsnowondem

Doesn’t exactly have a live arm.

Gumbygirl

Joe.

makeitsnowondem

Ah hell, this trade’s for McCarthy.

WCS

Somehow, the Jest will pick Christian Hackenberg.

Last edited 6 months ago by WCS
Gumbygirl

Joe Namath.

fleshwound_NPG

get a time machine and put this bears offense in the original tecmo super bowl so 9 year old me can experience his first boner even before adolescence instead of jim harbaugh’s fucking 25 pass control getting intercepted by lineman

Brocky

BANNER!!

fleshwound_NPG

still pissed (as you can tell) at the tecmo devs fucking harbs like that. ’90 harbs was NOT BAD AT ALL

Redshirt

Hey, my first video game QB was David Klingler and Jay Schroeder.

You want to trade horror stories, you’re talking to the wrong f——— cowboy.

scotchnaut

The Bears not fucking up the draft six ways from Sunday is a world I don’t want to live in.

Doktor Zymm

Didn’t they draft pretty well last year? They’ll still Bears it up, it’ll just be in a new and different way!

fleshwound_NPG

as long as they block all pit area code phone numbers from now on the front office is scary competent

Spur
BrettFavresColonoscopy

I don’t understand. Overpaying for Kirk Cousins is one thing, but reaching for his backup too? Wtf?

Kind of good for Penix, though, no pressure to start and will be super popular behind the other fuckwad in his decline.

makeitsnowondem

How long is Cousins’ contract? I could kind of understand paying for a short-term foil for him.

Mr. Ayo

2 years, 100 million. Penix will be 26 at that point. Odd choice for them.

Spur

ATL knows Penix was surrounded by 3 elite skill players and a OLine the Bills would kill for.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Do they though?

Doktor Zymm

Bears draft…JJ McCarthy

clint greasewood

comment image

King Hippo

Bears supposedly liked Odunze lots

Doktor Zymm

Called it

Gumbygirl

Not at all surprised they took him.

fleshwound_NPG

relegate the falcons to the acc coastal

scotchnaut

Penix-Typical of the Falcons drafting a guy that sounds like a discount building block.

Spur

Chicago select 2 more seasons of the Bear and a guest appearance for Caleb

makeitsnowondem

Gentlemen!

Spur

sup

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Where?

SonOfSpam

Atlanta: We are a boring-ass bad team and no one cares about us.
Atlanta: ……
Atlanta: PENIX PENIX PENIX

litre_cola

Arthur Blank is inserting a Penix in to the space butthole stadium.

Doktor Zymm

No one expected Penix to come this early!

SonOfSpam

“That wasn’t quick.”

-R. Pitino

TheRevanchist

It has never happened to him before. He’s sorry.

Spur

wow. ATL must be HIGH AS FUCK. this dude is almost 30 and hurt half the time.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Wat

Gumbygirl

Hmmmmmm.

2019347-43_tick___spoon.png
King Hippo

Nobody higher than the Sherman’s Ashes Draft HQ

fleshwound_NPG

THE DICK IS IN