Monday Morning Mock Draft: Habemus Papem!!

Gutentag drones.

We’ve got a draft based on current events for you today.  For the first time in tries the Cardinals got one right and finally named an American as Pope!

We’ll just ignore his Peruvian citizenship, the fact that he seems to have spent at least half his life living outside the USofA, and also that, for the vast majority of the life-span of the Holy Mother Church, the USofA did not exist.  The important thing is we finally go a guy of our own in the Holy See, his name is Bob, he’s from Chicago, and he’s a White Sox fan, so he knows something of suffering.

In keeping with tradition, upon being elevated to the papacy former Cardinal Robert Prevost took the name Leo XIV.  Why that tradition, you ask?  Because when that Jesus guy named Simon to his apostolic crew He told Simon he was changing his name to Peter, which I guess is how “fisher of men” translates in Aramaic*, (spoiler alert:  Jesus was probably not White), and then some stuff happened and Jesus got nailed to a cross and then He came back three days later and saw His shadow and there was six more weeks of Lent.  Or something.

*per the Wiki article I just looked up it may be a translation of ‘Cephas’ which has something to do with Jesus calling Peter the Rock on which He would build his church.

Look, I didn’t pay a lot of attention to the nuns during my parochial grade-school education, other than to make sure to duck when they started swinging, OK?

The point is, every Pope takes a new name when they become Pope.  And there have been some doozies throughout the last 1800-2000 years or so.  This week we draft your favoUrites, (the first Canadien Pope is gonna take the name ‘Doug,’ book that), from among those names.

The rules:  I.  Any Papal name is fair game, including anti-popes, schismatic popes, asthmatic popes, basically any kind of pope so long as they existed in real life.  No fictional popes, if you please.

II., once a name is taken that name is off the list:  we’re not, for instance, going to have fourteen Leos.  It’s the name, not the number, that counts.  Yes, that will limit the picks but I’m sure we can find enough to talk about to get through the day.

III., wait ten picks or a half hour before making your next pick.

IV.  Much like with John Paul, there is no IV.  Actually I’m pretty sure there are only two John Pauls.  Whatever, it’s time to get to picking!

With the first pick I take John Paul II.  Pretty dull name, pretty conservative guy, probably a reach in terms of draft value here.  BUT, he’s the first Pope I was aware of, he was the first Polish Pope, and when he was elected I was going to a parochial school named after St. Stanislaus.  Those Poles were so happy all us kids got free popcorn for lunch.  And that’s pretty much the most any Pope has ever done for me.

The rest of you are on the clock!

*Important Note:  Mrs. Horatio and I are doing missionary work in Puerto Rico this week, distributing paper towels to the needy and hopefully meeting Don T for what I’m told will be the most bestest roast pork ever.  Or maybe he said “get bombed on rum.”  Whichever.  The point being there is a very good chance I will not post next Monday, and you will be on your own.  If I decide to bring my computer with me I will put something together, (MAYBE), but if not someone will need to Karen Carpenter it.

(Youth pastor voice):  “You know who else was a carpenter?”

4.9 8 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
93 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Brick Meathook

I am in The City of Industry

I don’t think any of you can say that right now

Senor Weaselo

Weird way to describe those buildings by the BQE, but technically correct.

scotchnaut

Fins win! This is not a preview of The Cove 2: The Reckoning.

scotchnaut

Finland has tied it up-the sheer volume of the reindeer’s stamping in the forests must be scattering all the Juhani’s from their government-subsidized apartments.

SonOfSpam

Pope Lando, the first Pope from Cloud City. Hey what choice did he have?

comment image

scotchnaut

Pope Lando the First? I’m taking his successor, Pope Two By Sea.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

I’ll take Pope Sisinnius. I feel like he’d be Phil Collins’s favorite.

scotchnaut

:It’s very obvious that Sylvester has a learning disability. Why does no one understand this? Am I right?”

-Dr. Phil

scotchnaut
scotchnaut

I’d like to note that Flash and The Pan is the greatest name of a one-hit wonder band that will ever exist ever.

scotchnaut

Going with Leo The 1st. The record books say that Attila The Hun retreated from Rome after meeting with him because the latter was so impressed. The nickname “Leo The Lion Pope” has been sitting around for fucking centuries and hasn’t made it’s way on to a t-shirt yet? That ends as of 8am tomorrow morning when “Barney’s Decals and Used Sex Toys” opens, let me tell you what!

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

3. Pope Dionysius. I’ll be the PARTY POPE!

scotchnaut

Was going to pick him but historians say he whined too much.

Doktor Zymm

Good chance she’s apocryphal, but I choose to believe: Pope Joan
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Joan

Doktor Zymm

I always wondered what would happen if there was a pope with only one testicle, or if they dangled poorly.

And I always considered the argument that there isn’t contemporary evidence of a female pope to be kinda silly. The church was the only institution keeping good records in the European middle ages so if they wanted to keep something out of the historical record they could easily do so and it very well might live on only in popular memory to show up in writing again a few hundred years later

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

I don’t see why they engage in such a complicated ritual when they could just parade a particularly attractive altar boy in front of the candidate to see if they get a boner.

Doktor Zymm

Seems like some basic puppetry skills could get around that test though. In fact, I think there’s a whole show in Vegas based on that

Senor Weaselo

Also a bitchin’ motorcycle Persona belonging to Best Girl THAT’S RIGHT I SAID IT

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTfiFTGuwAM5hDg-aDBRsnW444Psa2ld1To4Q&usqp=CAU

scotchnaut

I hope he’s Down With The (Altitude) Sickness.

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

That was before the Vatican instituted mandatory HGH testing so it’s hard to say.

Gumbygirl

Hyginus, because he was so fresh and so clean!

Gumbygirl

.

1000006321
SonOfSpam

I’m taking 9th century Pope Formosus, the first Taiwanese pope (maybe). He’s cool because they tried and executed him. AFTER he was already dead. The incident was called the “Cadaver Synod” which may be a good fantasy football team name and/or a goth band,

scotchnaut

Wifey is going to take care of her nephew’s 18 month-old baby overnight. We’ve talked here and there about adopting or even trying to have another and I’m sure that’s going to start up again.

/begins research into reverse vasectomies

Doktor Zymm

Ask around to see if any of your relatives don’t want their kids first

BallsofLacrosseAndMapleSyrup

The only solution is to go no contact

scotchnaut

Sounds like you’ve got a severe case of the Somebody Else’s Problems For The Time Being.

scotchnaut

I’ll grab Julius. The historical record for some reason does not mention whether or not his vertical leap was as high as Dr. J’s but I think it’s safe to assume that he was the very first head of the Vatican that could dunk from the foul line.

Bonus Info: He had such a bad case of syphilis that supplicants couldn’t kiss his feet one Easter because they were covered in sores!

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

[makes the sign of the cross while a single tear runs down his cheek] – Rex Ryan

Doktor Zymm

I’m gonna take Zosimus. The Z makes it sound cool

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

All the kids will call you Space Pope Z.

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

2. Pope Constantine.

comment image

scotchnaut

Pope Sixtus IV. He banged his sister and had a kid with her, commissioned the Sistine Chapel and had a piece of medical equipment named for him.*

*is not remotely true

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

More like Pope SEXtus, amirite?

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

1. Pope Marcellus. I’d impose a new Inquisition and get medieval on the heretics’ asses.

Last edited 9 months ago by Rikki-Tikki-Deadly
Brocky

Pope Maximus von Shih Tzu

Patron Saint of barking at the vacuum and shaking like a leaf.

Also, someone call the groomer because his holiness needs a haircut

comment image

ArmedandHammered

I thought he was just rocking an ’80’s doo.

Brocky

More than I got, that’s for sure.

Wait a minute….

Doktor Zymm

Looks like a real pope to me, assuming that is actually the dog’s legal name.

Rikki-Tikki-Deadly

@Horatio I have been meaning to speak to you about taking over for a week, actually. I will handle next Monday.

BallsofLacrosseAndMapleSyrup

Thanks RTD

Don T

Nicolaus.
Just because, here’s my fave one: Nicolaus Arson
comment image

ArmedandHammered

From the thread last night, so far Noir is out of danger, his GI tract has started working, but they are keeping him to bleed me dry and to check out his elevated creatinine levels.

Doktor Zymm

Maybe your bunny has been taking body building supplements?

2Pack

Jacked Bunny = Happy Bunny

ArmedandHammered

More like dehydration.

Redshirt

Innocent, because someone choosing the Papal name “Innocent” almost begs coughed whispers of “bullshit”.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

comment image&ct=g

ArmedandHammered

That is a good defense! I am Innocent! As I am Innocent I cannot be guilty! Bring on the altar boys!

blaxabbath

I used to do work for a Pedro’s Honest Concrete.

Pedro was a crook.

Brick Meathook

General John Pope
Commander of the short-lived Army of Virginia (June to September 1862)

He was beaten by Gen Robert E Lee and his Army of Northern Virginia at the Second Battle of Bull Run (August 28-30 1862), although Pope controversially received little help from Gen George McClellan and his Army of the Potomac despite his orders to do so.

https://ibb.co/h5mVy7n

BugEyedBoo

Agapetus, because it’s pretty uncommon and porno-adjacent.

ballsofsteelandfury

THE GAPING POPE!

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Pope Goatse is next

ArmedandHammered

2 popes, 1 altar boy

BugEyedBoo

Don’t give them any ideas.

2Pack

My only choice today, because there is a story here. Pope Paul VI.

2Pack

OK here is the story. In August 1978 when he died I happened to be visiting Rome for the first time. As I cruised Vatican City as part of that, I joined a long line of people, thinking… boy this may be a pretty cool attraction here. For context, this was well before the internet. I lived in the barracks with no TV accept in the company day room which had one channel, AFN. I watched no TV and listened no radio. My Italian at the time was very weak. And the only things I applied off duty attention to was drinking and chasing women.

So Imagine my surprise when I passed ole Pope Paul number six lying in state. I get back to post and told all the boys about it at PT formation.

Then a month later when Pope John Paul I dies just a month into the gig, the obvious question everyone had was; “hey 2Pack, are you gonna go down to Rome and check out the dead pope again”?

blaxabbath

“Seen one dead Pope, seen ’em all.”

ballsofsteelandfury

That’s awesome!

Doktor Zymm

That’s way better than my accidentally seeing the Bishop of Naples story!

I still haven’t managed to see any important corpses. When I was in Beijing they were doing maintenance on the tip of Mao’s nose so I wasn’t able to see him

2Pack

They have Padre Pio life like preserved and in a glass display. They don’t mess around here with the dead holy folks.

Last edited 9 months ago by 2Pack
2Pack

merlin_135632022_7b3b7253-72f9-4abc-bf07-68117931dfaa-superJumbo
Doktor Zymm

Whoa

ballsofsteelandfury

Do tell!

Jimbo

Pope Benedict XV!. Kind of a forgettable pope. First thing I think of when I hear Benedict is eggs and then the traitor Benedict Arnold. Anyways, let’s all just forget about the whole Hitler youth thing.

Jimbo

Also, look at this face. Joe Pesci mixed with that emperor guy from Star Wars.

Screenshot-2025-05-19-at-6.23.11 AM
BrettFavresColonoscopy

Pope Boniface VIII. Is it pronounced Bone-uh-facci or Bony face? Who cares, this guy got his predecessor to resign so he could replace him and maybe got the king of France kidnapped and beaten. Mafia style poping right there.

https://popehistory.com/popes/pope-boniface-viii/

ballsofsteelandfury

I prefer Sister Boniface

comment imagev

Don T

🎶We gon do the pork, we gon do the rum, we gon talk shit aboOt alla youse behind yer back…🎶

ballsofsteelandfury

As is tradition…

Don T

John! Of “Dear John” and John XXIII / ❣️Vatican II❣️ fame.

Jimbo

Pope Alexander. I just started watching The Borgias on Paramount. Spoiler, that Pope fucked.

Last edited 9 months ago by Jimbo
Don T

Extra hammy Jeremy Irons YES! Oh, everytime he went “😠 Sforza” 👏 👏

Doktor Zymm

Pope Anacletus
It’s the pope name most like anal so I can get great trade value from Balls

ballsofsteelandfury

I”ll offer you a first round pick plus a pope to be named later!

WCS

Urban, because not only is not a real name, there’s been like six of them. And yeah, noted kicker-kicker Jaguras head coach Urban Meyer is named after one of them.

*Raised Catholic, John Paul II was pope for over half my life, and now there’s been three in 15 years or something. That’s kind of weird, because historically speaking, the average pope’s lifespan was like three years.

BrettFavresColonoscopy

Pope Pius X. How can you out-pious someone named Pius? O, you can’t.

Last edited 9 months ago by BrettFavresColonoscopy
BrettFavresColonoscopy

(Note: I’m a J-O-O and don’t know which Pius is the best Pope Pius, but I def wanted to cockblock the 12th, who was pontiff from 1939 into the 1950s, when the Catholic church was happy to put its head in the sand about some stuff happening elsewhere in Europe)